One of the most pressing issues in healthcare is actually a human resources issue with direct bearings on patient outcomes. Nurses are increasingly being expected to work twelve hour shifts, which has been touted as a means by which nurses can enjoy more days off and achieve an idea; work-life balance (Stimpfel, Sloane & Aiken, 2012, p. 2501). Yet in spite of the perceived benefits of a three-day work week, evidence has been showing that the twelve-hour shift is a direct cause of nurse burnout, turnover, job dissatisfaction, and other adverse outcomes include reduced quality of care. Stimpfel, Sloane & Aiken, 2012). Because patient outcomes are ultimately the most important thing in healthcare, I agree that whenever long hours become a problem for nursing staff, management teams need to revise their human resources policies.
The original research by Stimpfel, Sloane & Aiken (2012) shows that in their sample, “the longer the shift, the greater the likelihood of adverse nurse outcomes” such as burnout and decreased patient satisfaction with care (p. 2501). Yet what is most interesting about the Stimpfel, Sloane & Aiken (2012) article is that nurses seem to be unaware of the effects their longer shifts are having on their work quality and patient care. The researchers found that most nurses surveyed were actually satisfied with their schedules. What this seems to suggest is that nurses are making decisions about their work out of self-interest rather than being based on the principles of caring that undergird their profession.
My opinion is this: all healthcare institutions need to keep track of performance measures and patient perceptions of care. Whenever care quality decreases, or signs of burnout increase, the nurse leadership team needs to step in and reduce the number of hours on the nursing shift. This way, nurses who can somehow cope with the longer hours may do so but those who have less tolerance for the twelve-hour shift do not cause adverse effects.
References
Stimpfel, A.W., Sloane, D.M. & Aiken, L.H. (2012). The longer the shifts for hospital nurses, the higher the levels of burnout and patient dissatisfaction. Health Aff (Millwood). 2012 Nov; 31(11): 2501–2509.
Hour vs. 8-Hour Work Shifts The Effect of 12 Hour vs. 8-Hour Work Shifts on Health Care in Intensive Care Units Critical care areas, such as intensive care units (ICUs), may be very demanding and challenging places to work. ICU's are typically populated by very highly dependent patients. This work requires an increased staff to patient ratio, entails periods of high activity, the use of advanced equipment, and the need for
Nursing Burnout Polikandrioti M.( 2009). Burnout Syndrome. Retrieved March 24, from 2014 http://www.hsj.gr/volume3/issue4/340.pdf This article is on burnout syndrome which is described as a complex phenomena on the rise associated with a stressful work environment.it was described by Freudenberger in the mid-1970s and ever since it has been a subject of discussion. According to the article, the burnout syndrome is characterized using three dimensions; emotional exhaustion which refers to the depletion of
There is a need for the nurse to be proficient and efficient in her work, because ED's are experiencing an increasing number of patient visits, and there are normally more patient's waiting to be seen than is appropriate for the size of the facility's ED (GAO, 2008). If we compare the patient flow and the speed with which the ED nurse must work in order to accomplish her responsibilities and
autobiography of the author of this report. The remainder of the report will mostly focus on the four meta-paradigms of nursing. Of course, those meta-paradigms are patient, nurse, health and environment. The author will also offer two practice-specific concepts from the scholarly literature that can be applied to the career and environment of the author of this report. Next up will be a list of propositions that will number
jobs, but the one in which I was most significantly effected by ethical challenges was the time I spent working in the business office and customer service department of a large Health Management Organization (HMO). For reasons of anonymity and because I truly believe that my experiences may not have been universal for the entire organization, I prefer not to name the organization. In order to set the stage,
Nurses are considered the backbone of the medical care-giver community. Good quality patient care centers on having a competent educated nursing labor force. There is a wealth of empirical evidence that has demonstrated Baccalaureate (BSN) nurses are associated with fewer medication errors, lower mortality rates, and greater overall positive patient outcomes than nurses at lower levels of educational achievement. For example, Brady, Malone, and Fleming (2009) performed an extensive literature
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now